For: PH-Nz
To answer your question, I think to be able to have a chance on reaching our National Team goal which is the championship, We must choose the best players in our twelve man rosters. We cannot experiment on this, like you are telling us to choose between the two of your personal perspective. So I hope we could help each other on finding or recruiting the best players that have the right skills that can compliment and help this team reach our mission. (But if you ask to choose one? I might choose the second one, a team that has a starting line-up of star or best players while their bench are full of not good enough player's. Why? You can use your best players by starting and playing them maybe 3/4 of the game or by using the tactics of DEPTH CHART UNTIL THE FOURTH QUARTER - your coach will choose the best player on that quarter that can help the team wins.)