Sorry there have been so many posts these few days and everybody seems to refer to a little bit of the same thing, so I just share some of my opinions and not quote anyone.
What what I want to talk about is training
I said long time ago in the [U21 season 19] post that a practical preoblem which always exists is the conflict between own team benefit and U21 benefit. I think some of you have also mentioned this point previously, but lemme elaborate and share what I saw in the past.
Situation 1: A "green" team (probably 1 in II.1 -II.4) gets a great draftee. We approach him, ask him to train, tell him how to train, keep monitoring, and that's all. This situation is common and easy to manage. They know little about the game and training. Do not really have a team plan. No pressure for result. They probably will train. What we need to do is to explain everything patiently and clearly to make sure they do not train wrongly.
Situation 2: A "training" team gets another trainee, but the training plan conflicts (say 1 centre and 1 PG, or 2 PGs but with big difference in skill set). Ask them to keep the better ones or the positions that they need more, then the other trainees. End up some trainees going overseas, but past experience show that these players do get trained. Sabotage is quite rare I think. (Just imagine if you buy an ordinary pallstar $3XXX trainee and you get bbmail from scout every week, will you feel shocked and sorry?) After all, this situation is not bad
Situation 3: A "competitive" team in a "competitive" league gets a great draftee. Unless the team says "oh this draftee is great! I will do nothing from now on except training. Perhaps I'll buy 1 and 2 more to train together, we'll be in trouble. Like Audi and STN have mentioned, you can't blame them to put own team interest first. Probably they need to get a few pops from their star players and need to train them for a season, and the 18yo simply don't fit in the plan. Even if they can train, they mostly can only train 1 and probably can't train in a way that you'd like. So? Ask them to sell, and go overseas again... SGP really don't have many teams out there ready for a new trainee anytime.
Conclusion: When we talk about U21, it's all about "human resources". You need those a dozen good talents to realize their potential so as to get good result for the U21 and NT. so U21 manager has to place the benefit of the trainees at the first place. You need to "fight" for the trainees. It's easy for situation 1 because U21 interest fits own team interest. But how about situation 3? And an excellent SGP player may end up serving a foreign club forever. But this is still better than a young prospect being wasted. The role of U21 manager is quite passive. We often talk about how would we train a player but to realize that is difficult. Relentless effort, sincerity, good interactive skills are essential and my strengths.