I have question on the 5 star players. Say if you have 6 players with 5 stars and only one of them was scouted for a 2nd time. That one player has a A- grade and 3 star potential.
With a 5 star ranking, A- is the worse you can get and 3 star potential is normal. Wouldn't you just rank the guy last out of your six 5 star players. Notwithstanding his 3 star potential, you cannot get any worse than A- with your 5 star guys, no?