Hmm... this is always an interesting one. I personally would take 5/3 A+ 18 year old and hope he has all star potential but that's just my opinion. I would keep looking for better prospects. The 19 year old has better potential but it isn't worth the fact that he has already missed his 18 year old season. If the 19 year old were to have 5 potential then I would definitely tell you to go for him, but since he doesn't Player 1 is the way to go. He might turn into a nice PF depending on his skills.
Murray/Harris/MPJ/Grant/Jokic - 2020 NBA Champs